Documenting Sources
The Purposes of Documentation
1. To give credit where it is due. You are, after all, taking
someone else's ideas, knowledge, etc. The least you can do is to give them
credit for it (especially if it might be wrong).
2. To increase your credibility. Why should anyone believe you
(or me) about the dangers of nuclear waste, about when a fetus is a human
being, about the cost of space exploration, etc.? It is perfectly acceptable,
even necessary for non-experts to discuss -- and write about -- questions
such as these. But if we want to be taken seriously, we need to show that
we have done some studying ourselves. By citing experts in the field, in
other words, we can increase the strength of our arguments.
3. To allow the reader to find more information. If you are really
interested in something that you are reading about, you will probably want
to find still more that is written about the topic. Your documentation
(citations) enable your readers to find your source material and read it
for themselves -- including the materials that you did not quote or paraphrase.
The Logic of Documentation
There are two main systems for reporting
your source material within your writing. They are the APA (American Psychological
Association) and the New MLA (Modern Language Association). We will
be using the new MLA, but the logic behind both systems is essentially
the same. Once you understand this logic, documentation should be relatively
easy to do.
The main objective of documentation
is to enable your reader to find (physically) the page or other source
where you got the information. Suppose, for example, that someone is reading
your essay and reads a quotation or a paraphrase of someone else's ideas.
Where did it come from? After the quotation or paraphrase, you should have
included parentheses ( ) within which you included just enough information
for your reader to find your source in your "Works Cited" list. In
almost every case, therefore, what you put in the parentheses are the first
words from that source's listing in your "Works Cited." (See the Guide
for examples.) Unless your written source is only one page long, this ALWAYS
includes the page number. Your reader, in other words, should be able to
look at the information within the parentheses, go to your "Works Cited"
list, and find the source. The "Works Cited" list should include the author's
name, the title, etc., as explained in the Guide. Because a "Works Cited"
list can become very long, you should arrange the items in it in alphabetical
order to make them easier for your reader to find.
1. In the text, give two things:
A. just enough information for the reader to find the work in the "Works
Cited List"
B. page references.
2. In the "Works Cited" List,
A. include all required information,
B. arrange the list in alphabetical order.
Integrating Source Material into
Your Writing
Although you are expected
to incorporate research sources into a research paper, some students are
under the misconception that such a paper is just a collection of other
people's ideas, facts, and even organization. In a research paper, your
job is to ask a question, search for information that would answer it,
and then evaluate that information, come to some conclusions about it,
and organize it to support your conclusions. Since whatever you write is
taken to be your idea or your knowledge, this raises the question of how
you should introduce other people's ideas into your writing.
The thesis and topic
sentences of your essay should always be yours. Don't begin a paragraph
with a paraphrase. Rarely, you can begin one with a quotation. (The quotation
marks will indicate that you are presenting someone else's idea.) As you
research a topic, you will find some information in numerous sources. This
is considered common knowledge. Some of it, you will remember. Whatever
you can write, as you draft your essay, without looking at your source
material, is considered to be your ideas or knowledge. When you do refer
to your notes or to sources as you draft, you should put an in-text citation
(in parentheses) at the end of that material, and you should introduce
that material with an introductory phrase (to let your reader know that
what is coming is someone else's idea or opinion).
Examples of introductory
phrases are:
According to Mark Newman, a biologist at the
Center for Disease Control, ....
Earnest Hemmingway, a well-known novelist, claims
that ....
In the words of Mary Sheffield, who has just
returned from Hong Kong, "...."
Notice that in each example, I have given the source's
name plus a brief description. Your description should include the primary
credentials of your source, thereby strengthening the credibility of your
argument. I assume, for example, that if you cite Mark Newman, you will
be discussing something related to biology or diseases, and not to economics.
Unless you have a specific reason for doing so, do not include the title
of the work you are citing from in your description. That information has
to be included in the Works Cited list anyway, and in your essay
it will simply take up space and be a distraction. |