From "The Ugly Duckling" by E. Louise Smythe Analysis Key A duck made her nest (DO) {under some leaves}. | She sat {on the eggs} to keep them warm [#1]. | {At last} the eggs broke, one {after the other} [#2]. | Little ducks came out. | Only one egg was left (P). | It was a very large one (PN). | {At last} it broke, | and out came a big, ugly duckling. | [DO of "said" "What a big duckling!"] [#3] said the old duck. | "He does not look {like us}. | Can he be a turkey (PN)? | – We will see. | [Adv. to "not" If he does not like the water (DO)], he is not a duck (PN)." | The next day [NuA] the mother duck took her ducklings (DO) {to the pond}. | Notes 2. Within KISS, there are two ways to explain this "one." First, it can be considered an appositive to "eggs." Second, it can be explained as a noun used as an adverb. The phrase "after the other" here is an adjective, simply because it obviously connects to the pronoun "one." Note that the appositive is a reduction of a clause – "One *broke* after the other." In this full form, "after the other" functions as an adverb to broke." 3. Expect the students to be confused by this clause that functions as a direct object. |