Netscape® Communicator 4.0
Pennsylvania College of Technology
Dr. Vavra's ENL 121: Lit & Comp
 Fall 1998: MP # 1 
A Set of Essays 
on Short Stories

Paper # 248

 Dr. Vavra's Course Menu Main ENL 121 Menu Current MP #1 Assignment
Back to Menu for this Set of Papers

ENL 121-05
Oct 1, 1998
Major Paper # 1

A Triumphant Indifference


1     Gene Giraudoux, the French playwright wrote “If two people who love each other let a single instant wedge itself between them, it grows—it becomes a month, a year, a century; it becomes too late.” [Source?] Based on the introduction of the author F[Z]ora Hurston, it is possible this story Sweat [Titles] is about the lives of real people in the South. The story focuses on one type of relationship that can exist between husbands and wives.  The men can be abusive and the women will try to survive by working from their homes from dawn to dusk to make ends meet. The theme of this story is survival in the face of (or in spite of) adversity. [New paragraph] The main character’s key to survival is her triumphant indifference to her husband's aggression.

2     [No paragraph] From the beginning of the marriage Delia learned to live with adversity.  [Topic sentence appears to be from a plot summary.] She comes to realize Sykes is not a person she can count on for a home, support and income.  His cruel sense of humor is manifested in the scenes where he places the whip on Delia’s shoulder leading her to believe it is a snake, a creature that fills her with terror. He demonstrates his carefree and careless nature, [no ,] by spending money that Delia earns to court another woman.

3     African American women have a history of being church going, God fearing individuals who are content to work hard for a living. To survive they learn to be well organized and efficient with time and money. The opinions of the townspeople lead a person to question what Delia was like before she got married and became indifferent to Sykes jealousy and resentful attitude toward her working for white folk.  Sweat and religion are her keys to survival.

4     Why does Delia remain passive through all the turmoil in her life? She knows that physically she is no match for Sykes.  She thwarts his attempts to draw her into confrontations by remaining indifferent to his abuse. It states in the beginning of the story that she gave up on love when Sykes started cheating on her. Without love Delia needs to focus her energy on other things to make her life worthwhile.  She chooses her work, house, trees and flower garden as the most important aspects of her life, all earned by her sweat. [Nice point] Her indifference to Sykes’s attempts to drive her away by sabotaging her life, makes his efforts fail.

5     The title of the story is not just the title of the work discussed; rather the author F[Z]ora Hurston gives the reader clues to what they are reading. [This is a poor topic sentence for this section. "The title of the story is symbolic."] Throughout the story several symbols are revealed [used].  From Webster’s dictionary the title Sweat has several definitions that describe the characters in this story.  Sweat means [Diction] a person who is hard working, in a state of anxiety, to be under strain or waits anxiously, these describe Delia when she gets married, as she passes through the years, and awaits Sykes death. [CS -1]  It also means to give the third degree or to force a person to work hard. This would describe the treatment Sykes forces Delia to endure. [It has still other implications in the story.]

6     Another area of symbolism would be the snake, seen as an extension of Sykes.  The snake torments Delia with his constant presence, making her live in fear until she chooses to become indifferent to him.  Again she triumphs over adversity and remains in her home.  When Sykes fumbles in the darkness, this symbolizes that life is coming to an end.  In the darkness, Sykes is destroyed by his own deed. The snake, his own evil idea, causes his death.

7     One of the most important conflicts noted is spouse vs. spouse. [Poor topic sentence -- it doesn't cover the paragraph.]A H[h]usband should be the bread winner and care for his wife and home, but in this situation the roles are reversed.  The wife has built a home, planted a garden and learned to be content with a cheating husband.  Another conflict is passive vs. aggressive, Delia is passive and content to live her life as non-argumentative, and Sykes is aggressive, beating his wife because he is resentful and jealous of the time she spends working and the income she earns. [CS -1] Good vs. evil is another conflict, but who is good and who is evil?  Sykes appears evil throughout the story; however, Delia lets him die in the end making excuses why she can’t help him. [Which of these conflicts is the most important? Why?]

8     For generations women have been the weaker sex even though they give birth, take care of the home, put food on the table, work outside the home, and become nurses when necessary.  Women can persevere when times are tough and man proves to be weak. [In what way did Sykes "prove to be weak"?]

[This is a competent essay, but it could delve deeper into the story. Delia certainly "survives," at least physically, but her position at the end of the story does not appear enviable. She is, it appears, sweating. Note the references to heat and to the cool earth. Why is she sweating?]


Outline
1
I.  Intro. & thesis: The theme of this story is survival in the face of (or in spite of) adversity. 
2 II.  How it is developed by author [Critical concept?]
     A.  What does it make you understand about Delia’s character? 
      1.  How she lives with adversity 
3
      2.  Triumph from indifference 
4
    B.   How she was passive 
      1.  house 
      2.  garden 
5 III.  Symbols 
    A.   Sweat 
      1.  Definitions of Sweat
      2. ?
6
    B.  Snake 
      1.  Evil 
      2.  Extension of Sykes disposition 
      3.   Fear 
    C.  Darkness 
      1.  death 
      2.  destroyed by own deed [Doesn't this belong under "snake"?]
7 IV.  Conflicts 
    A.  Spouse vs. Spouse 
    B.  Passive  vs. Aggressive 
    C.  Good vs. Evil 
8 V.   Conclusion



ENL 121 (Vavra) Grading Sheet for MP1 (1 of 2)
Possible
Points
Student's
Grading
Instructor's
Grading
Description Totals
Audience (20)  16
0 - 3    3 The essay has a good introductory paragraph.
0 - 3    2 The essay has a good concluding paragraph.
0 - 4
   1 The essay goes beyond the obvious. [Part of the problem here is that there is not a single brief quotation from the story which is used by the writer to support or explore a point in the essay.]
0-10   10  The essay does not simply retell the story.
Thesis (20)  15
0 - 5    4 The thesis is clearly identifiable, somewhere near the beginning of the essay.
0 - 5    3 The thesis enables an interpretation, not a retelling, of the story.
0 - 5    5 The thesis reflects at least an average understanding of the concepts studied.
0 - 5    3 The thesis reflects an above average understanding of the concepts studied and the story.
 Organization (20)  15
0 - 5    5 The essay has at least four paragraphs.
0 - 5    3 Topic sentences relate paragraphs to the thesis.
0 - 5
   4 Topic sentences cover paragraphs.
0 - 5    3 Outline and paragraphs reflect subdivisions of major points. [The weakness is in the topic sentences of the paragraphs.]
Details (20)  13
5    5 The essay includes some details.
0 - 5    2 One concept (__characterization?_)  is explained in good detail.
0 - 5    3 A second concept (__symbols___) is explained in good detail.
0 - 5    3 A third concept (__conflicts__) is explained in good detail.

(2 of 2)

Possible
Points
Student's
Grading
Instructor's
Grading
Description Totals
Style (20)  16
0 - 3    2 Words are used correctly and accurately. ["Zora," "revealed," "means"]
0 - 2    2 There are no (few) errors in usage.
0 - 2    2 Pronouns are used correctly.
0 - 2    2 Verb forms and tenses are used correctly.
0 - 3    3 All sentences are comprehensible.
0 - 2    1 Sentence structure is mature and varied.
0 - 4
   2 Underlining, italics, and quotation marks are used correctly. [Titles; nothing quoted from story]
0 - 2
   2 There are few or no sloppy errors.
Minus Style Penalty Points (May be regained by correcting errors) -2
Basic Grade for the Essay (100)  73
Penalty Points: - __________ Late          -___________ Other -
Bonus Points (9 possible) + 4
0 - 3     Brainstorming
0 - 3    1 Outlining
0 - 3    3 Revision
Final Grade for the Essay  77
Hostage Fifty: 
    Apostrophe
If anything is written in the "Hostage Fifty" block, read the Additional Requirements for Major Papers.

Student's Comments: (You can also use the back of either page.)


Student's Log

Codes: B = Brainstorming; RR = Reading/Research; O =Outlining; TC = Tutoring Center;
D = Drafting; RV = Revising; E =Editing; G = Grading; T =Typing

NOTE: Revising = RV. Remember: use only one code per entry. (See Instructions.)

I used a word-processor __x___while drafting ___x__ while revising ___x__ to type my paper.
 

Date: Code Started Stopped Minutes Comments
9/23
 RR
1800 
2200 
240 
reading stories to decide which one to do
9/24 
2030 
2130 
60 
writing [?] different angles to story
9/25 
1700 
1800 
60 
working on outline, thesis, theme
 
1330 
1530 
120 
coming up with different approaches to write paper
 
T [D]
1800 
2200 
240 
typing a rough draft
9/26 
T [D]
 1300
1330 
30 
adding to draft
9/27 D 1000 1100 60 completing draft
  RV 1300 1330 30 revising and adding to draft
9/28 TC 1800 1840 40 tutor reading, making corrections and additions
9/29 RR 1910 1930 20 looking for quote
9/30 E 1900 2000 60 editing and revising draft from tutor, adding quote
10/1 D [T} 1830 1940 80 putting everything together to hand in draft, paper logs, floppy disk

Distribution of Time:

Process Minutes % of Total
Brainstorming
 180
 17
Read/Research
 260
 25
Outlining
 60
 6
Tutoring Center
 40
 4
Drafting
 330
 32
Revising
 30
 3
Editing
 60
 6
Grading
 0
 0
Typing
 80
 8
Total
 1040
= 17.3 hours