Dr. Vavra's Main Menu

KISS Grammar Home Page

Cobweb Corner

The 1986 Study

Record Number: W4N07

Level Three: Add Clauses

Back to Fourth Grade Writers' Menu

      Subordinate clauses are in brackets [ ]. / represents the vertical line at the end of a main clause.  The font size of words aleady analyzed has been decreased. The color codes for adjectives, adverbs, and prepositional phrases have been deleted because too many colors seemed distracting. Words which remain to be analyzed are still in 14-point black. 

     My family Note #1 / I have four people {in my family.} / 

There is a mother, father, sister and me. /  We like to play

tennis, ride bikes, take walks and do a lot {of other things.} /

First I'll tell you {about my mommy.} / She doesn't have a job. /

she's a housewife / [Adv to "goes out" while Note #2 I am {in 

school}] my mom goes out. / Now my dad drives a bread truck

{for Xxxxxx baking company.} / We get a lot {of donuts, pies, 

cookies and cupcakes.} / My sister is a pain sometimes / but we 

get along pretty good. / She thinks [DO of "thinks" she's a big 

girl [Adv to "is" Note #3 when she hangs {from the bars} {in our 

yard.}]] / And last it's me. / Well I like to do gymnastics, play

tennis, ride bike and play soccer. /

     My house is {on 428 Xxx Drive.} / It is not very big. / It's

a one story five rooms. / Plus a pantrey. Note #4 / I have a

bathroom, kitchen, living room and two bedrooms. / {Outside

of my house}I have a carport {with shads} and a swing. / {In the

yard} we have a small playground {with bars swingset and a plastic 

horse} [Adj to "horse"  we can ride on. ] / {In two} {of our trees} 

there are squirrel boxes / that's all {about my house.} /

     The worst day [Adj to "day"  I spent] was [Adv to "was" Note

 when my momy told me [DO of "told"  my aunt died and

Note #5 had to go {to school.} ]] / I worried and worried all day

long. /  She was {on oxgen} / and she went to sleep / my other 

aunt came to check {on her} / and [Adv to "was laying"  when 

she came down] she was laying {on the bed.} /
 

Notes

1. I would not even mention to fourth graders that this is a fragment unless we were syntactically analyzing the passage. Even then, I would not make a big deal about it.

2. This sentence is a good example of the purpose of "correct" punctuation. In processing this sentence the reader gets "she's a housewife while I am in school" which suggests that when the writer is not in school, the mother is not a housewife. Then the reader gets the "my mom goes out" which changes the meaning of the "while" clause, thereby confusing the reader. 
     Although some primary school teachers think that fourth graders can analyze clauses and understand the grammatical explanation, I seriously doubt it -- some of my college Freshmen have trouble with it. In working with fourth graders, I would simply appeal to their sense of a sentence -- Does it mean "She's a housewife while I am in school" or does it mean "While I am in school, my mom goes out"? In other words, I would not use the word "clause."

3. This "when" clause could also be interpreted as modifying "thinks," the verb in the main clause.

4. Note how, in analyzing their own writing, students will run actoss fragments such as this -- without a subject of verb. Because the majority of the sentences they have analyzed have subjects and verbs, and becaue we teachers tell students that they should have, students will see for themselves that something is wrong. Teachers should simply suggest that the fragment can probably be joined either to the preceding or the following sentence. In this case, "a one story *with* five rooms, plus a pantry."

5. In discussing "had" in Level Two, I called it a "silly" mistake, but note that it may well have been caused by the highly unusual combination of three subordinate clauses in one main clause. Actually, the student was probably trying for four subordinate clauses -- "The worst day [I spent] was [when my momy told me [my aunt died] and [*that I* had to go to school]]." For a fourth grader, that is a very big stretch.
 
 

Progress:
Total Words = 254 Words %
L1: In Prep Phrases  64  25
L1A: + Adj. & Averbs 48 44
L2: + S / V / C 105 85
L3: + Clauses 11 90

Back to Fourth Grade Writers' Menu